Last week we spoke about omel Torah. Rovo (Sanhedrin 99b) compares omel Torah to a long bag. A long bag makes it easy for a person to find their coins. A long bag is a shallow bag that extends along its length (as opposed to a deep bag, which extends downwards to its depth). From here we saw that ameilus means to have things organized.
We will explain what ameilus in Torah is. First, let us look at the gemorah in Shabbos that says that we need to fix times for Torah. Rashi explains the need for this because a person must be involved in derech eretz. Therefore, if a person doesn’t set times for this, he will be drawn to derech eretz all day.
Derech Eretz makes it very difficult for a person to do anything else besides for it. The only solution is to fix times for learning.
I was once at a friend’s shevah berachos. This friend was very wealthy, and he had invited other very wealthy friends. I posed a question to the people around me. I asked them why it was that people can work in their jobs for ten or eleven hours, but when I try to learn for four or five hours, I can’t manage.
The non-wealthy people around the table answered that the working people want money, and this is what pushes them. I dismissed this answer, saying it does not explain the phenomenon.
They suggested that I go and ask one of the wealthy men present. He gave an unequivocal response, which was certainly because he wanted money. All those present took this as an approbation that they were correct.
I was not convinced. I hold like Rashi. Rashi doesn’t mention money, but just that derech eretz pulls a person to pursue it all day long. So, I was still left with the question of why derech eretz is so all-encompassing.
The web of the Mashgiach
In fact, I discussed this question with the Mashgiach. I asked him why Rashi says that derech eretz draws a person after it to do nothing else all day besides it. He instantly explained it by saying that a person gets caught by the ‘web of obligations’ where one thing leads to another and onwards.
It’s a superficial approach to explain this phenomenon based on a desire for money.
We don’t work to achieve a ‘vision.’
Similarly, if you think that I was prepared to work for almost seven hours straight with my son last week, constructing the shelves in my room, because I had a preconceived idea of how nice it would look, then you are mistaken. This is superficial- a vision can’t keep a person busy for so long. The vision for money and the vision for how the shelves will look once they are completed cannot motivate a person for so long. The psychological books nowadays are replete with the idea of vision but it’s not true.
When I constructed the shelves, which are each three meters long, I first needed to ensure that the top shelf was high enough and had enough room for the gemorahs to fit. I drilled a hole on the first side and then needed to match up a hole at the same height on the corresponding side. I needed to be very careful so that the shelf would be very flat. I experienced how one job led to the next, and then to the next, and so on.
What is ameilus?
Now we will return to the gemorah in Sanhedrin 99b. The gemorah speaks about omel melachah, sichah, and Torah. What is the omel? Creating an attitude of pursuing one thing that leads to the next, and so on.
According to this definition, there is a great gain for us. When a person is thinking about creating a mehalech in avodas Hashem, a mehalech cannot be created based on one’s feelings alone. The first reason is that avodah cannot be based only on yourself. Rather, it needs to be sourced in the Torah. Secondly, if you try to present this to an audience and the whole impetus comes from your feelings, that is irresponsible.
Reb Yisroel Salanter speaks about the milchemes hayetzer. He says that the yetzer hara wants immediate satisfaction. The seichel, on the other hand, perceives consequences. Part of this milchamah requires a person to listen to his seichel. However, nowadays he says that consequences (punishments, Gehinnom, etc.) no longer work for us.
Nevertheless, the structure should remain the same. As I explained, the seichel must remain strong. We must use the seichel to plan the next step, then the next, and so on. In this way, the yetzer will have no way of entering. In other words, the process that I am laying out is based on a Torah source of Reb Yisroel.
I am not saying that I am using the same raw material that Reb Yisroel is talking about, using the ingredient of the seichel to perceive consequences. Nevertheless, I am saying the same as Reb Yisroel, since the seichel must plan step by step. The seichel, which sees into the future, is being used to stop the yetzer from entering.
Ameilus doesn’t mean exhaustion of all the kochos. Rather, the omel means that you are maintaining your mehalech and you pursue the mehalech.
Ameilus in Torah-not about a vision of the end product
What is ameilus in Torah?
If ameilus means being organized and having a clear vision of what you hope to produce, then this isn’t relevant to Torah. Rashi in Sanhedrin says that a person will not be successful if he sets himself a time for finishing a masechta. If so, we see that Torah is not about a plan or a vision. Nevertheless, according to what we have been saying the ameilus in Torah is like ameilus for all other matters. We do not need to have a whole vision of what will be at the end. When constructing shelves, we do not need to start with a vision of the end product. Instead, we need to know what the next step is. Similarly, ameilus in Torah only requires knowing and moving forward to the next step, then to the next, one step at a time.
This step-by-step process that we are talking about is harder in ruchniyus and in Torah than in mundane matters such as building shelves. However, we need to invest in this also for ruchniyus and Torah. Once we do this, the yetzer will no longer have a way in.
I personally experienced this type of ameilus in Torah when learning with Rav Mendal Artic. When he learned every single line of Reb Chaim Brisker, he always looked for the nafka minah in the sugyah. He looked back into the sugyah a hundred times! This is the ameilus that I am talking about. This ameilus means that a person is working something out the whole time and then, based on that, working out how everything else fits with it. If you keep doing this, then you will be omel batorah.
Rashi’s long bag-ameilus batorah
Let us return to the pshat of Rashi, which says that ameilus is like a long bag. I would like to fit my explanation of Rashi’s long bag with how this describes the body toiling in Torah.
The body can be in a state of being alert or being relaxed. Alertness is a tenuah in the body and not just in the mind.
Reb Chatzkel once fell asleep whilst learning. From then on, he never sat and learned in a chair with a back support. This was to keep him alert. When Rovo said that an omel batorah‘s body is toiling in Torah, I think he meant that, because a person is in a mehalech, he is alert the whole time. This is also a bodily description.
From our ameilus, we are not trying to reach a goal. We are not talking about working through a mehalech, leading from one thing to the next, to achieve a goal or vision. This is superficial and will lead to disappointment and pressure. Instead, we are constantly looking for the next natural step in the process.
Written by Rabbi Rapport