New topic! What does it mean to be mesudar? It doesn’t just mean to be a yekkah. Rather, it is based on ratzon.
Home > Lessons > Morality > Planning or Willpower > Plan Your Life – or Willpower? > Planning or Willpower – First Vaad – Defining the Topic
New topic! What does it mean to be mesudar? It doesn’t just mean to be a yekkah. Rather, it is based on ratzon.
Planning or Willpower – First Vaad – Defining the Topic
We will begin to work on a new topic called ‘seder’. What does it mean to make a seder for oneself?
First, we will contemplate what the idea of seder is in the world.
We say המסדר את הכוכבים כרצונו. Hashem was mesader the stars according to His ratzon. So we see that seder and ratzon are connected. Let’s think about this, and we will arrive at a new perspective on the meaning of seder.
Most of us think that being mesudar means being a yekkah and keeping to time with great precision! Such an approach to being mesudar brings with it tremendous pressure. How do people cope with such pressures? They use their willpower to ensure they live up to their pressured time constraints. However, this approach is a mistake.
Seder is the way to express the ratzon
To understand the correct meaning of seder, let us look at the root of all musagim-Hashem. Hashem wanted a world. In Pirkei Avos, it says that Hashem made the world with 10 maamarim (statements). Hashem could have made it with one maamar, but to give reward to the tzaddikim and punishment to the reshaim, He made it with 10 maamarim.
The ratzon of Hashem for the world could have been fulfilled or expressed in different ways. It could have been achieved through one maamar, just as through 10 maamarim. Each of these ways is a different mehalech, or seder, for creating the world.
The Ramchal in Daas Tevunos is very clear that the difference between making the world with one maamar or 10 maamarim lies in how these two options would have different sedarim in the world (and not in how the world would be different).
The Daas Tevunos says that Hashem created a seder of 10 maamaros for the creation of the world. Hashem has a ratzon for the creation of the world, and this ratzon can be expressed through various mehalchim. Ratzon is very deep, and it can therefore be expressed in multiple ways.
Moreover, we see that Hashem gave Odom Harishon a mitzvah not to eat from the etz hadaas, but from the etz hachaim, and Odom didn’t fulfill His ratzon. Nevertheless, Hashem still kept His ratzon. He still wanted that Odom through his avodah should metaken the world. The ratzon didn’t change; only the sedarim for pursuing it changed.
Similarly, Hashem wanted Klal Yisroel to enter into Eretz Yisroel. However, they did the chet hameraglim, which prevented their entering. Nevertheless, Hashem’s ratzon for them to enter was unchanged from this incident. The way to reach their entrance would now instead be 40 years later, with a different generation.
Ratzon and Seder of Humans
Similarly, the ratzon of humans works in the same way. Before we begin anything, we have a ratzon. The ratzon needs to create a seder, and there are different options of seder available to any given ratzon. All these options exist within the ratzon.
People quote a maamar that says, ‘nothing stands in front of the ratzon.’ I think that this has been taken from non-Jewish sources. This is a misconception. People understand this through the well-known principle of willpower. This means forcing oneself to fulfill one’s ratzon. If you really want the thing, then you will force yourself to overcome any obstacles. It is incorrect to think that whenever you really want something, you can guarantee that you will always attain your want.
‘Nothing stands in front of the ratzon’ really means that you want something, and you work on achieving it through a certain seder. You then encounter an obstacle, so you try to achieve it through a different seder. But regardless of the seder you employ, the ratzon stays the same. The problems along the way will interfere with the sedorim but not with the ratzon.
Do you really think that the way of avodah could be mere determination, more pressure, and forcing yourself to persevere past all obstacles? No! Avodah requires seichel to create new sedorim and mehalchim for achieving the original ratzon.
Let’s illustrate this by looking at ourselves. I dealt with someone who was very connected to the news, to the point that it disrupted his involvement with other things. He decided to stop following the news. Instead, he started reading biographies of politicians. The ratzon stayed for him. He just changed the mehalech!
When obstacles prevent the ratzon from being fulfilled, the ratzon will naturally find another way to express itself. You do not need to force the issue to find another way to express your ratzon.
What we need to work on is that from the beginning of our endeavour for anything, it should be recognizable straight away that we want a mehalech. It must not be that we only want the end result. Instead, we need to want the mehalech and seder itself. The mehalech and the seder must not simply be a technical means to an end. At every step of the pursuit for something, it needs to be recognized that there is a ratzon. This means that we need ratzon and seder to be connected.
One might ask me why I am so punctual in the beginning of my vaadim and in their ending. The reason is not that I am a yekkah. The simple explanation is that I have a ratzon to be mechabed the listeners, that they have a right to know when the shiur will begin and when it will end. My need to work according to a seder is not seder alone, but it is accompanied by a ratzon.
Seder without an accompanying ratzon is empty. A seder just for the sake of being on time for everything is empty. In such a case, there is no meaningful ratzon other than starting and leaving on time.
Seder to go alongside a ratzon is not a rigid thing at all. A person starts with a ratzon. Then an obstacle arrives, and they need to change and find a new seder.
The people who went up to Eretz Yisroel against the ratzon of Hashem were the ones who said, ‘Nothing stands against the ratzon.’ They stood rigid and insisted on going to Eretz Yisroel with the original seder and mehalech. Really, Hashem wanted them to enter Eretz Yisroel through a new, different seder.
If somebody says they have a seder but is also flexible about it, this is a contradiction. However, when there is a ratzon behind the seder, this gives flexibility-you will change the seder to actualize the ratzon. Then you can have sedorim whilst remaining flexible.
It starts from having real ratzonos
One of our biggest problems is that we don’t really have a ratzon for anything. We spend our days simply reacting to what is happening. For example, what do we want from our learning? If we want to sit next to a sefer and to read text, this falls short of what learning is. If we want to understand something, then this is learning. But, how do we go about doing this? We suffer from not knowing what exactly we want. Then even if we know what we want, we don’t know how to be mesader ourselves to achieve it.
Some people think that the whole structure of being mesudar in our learning in Kollel is to do shemiras hasedorim. This is a mistake. Learning is a mehalech, but shemiras hasedorim is not.
I recommend experimenting by taking, for example, an apple and having a ratzon to see chessed Hashem from eating this apple. Since the ratzon needs to create a seder, it must be a slow, deliberate swallowing. There needs to be a seder of eating to experience chessed Hashem. Every single step of the eating from the berachah, the eating and the chewing until the berachah acharonah all need to express the ratzon of seeing chessed Hashem.
Say a person wants to learn in a night Kollel. If so, he can’t eat a big, heavy meat supper, which will tire him out. He cannot rely on the fact that, despite feeling exhausted from his heavy meal, he will nevertheless force himself to go to kolel come what may. This does not constitute being mesudar. There is no recognizable ratzon being expressed in how he eats and how much he eats. Going to night Kollel purely through willpower, overcoming all the stumbling blocks, does not constitute being mesudar to go to learn. Instead, the ratzon to learn in the night Kollel needs to begin before going. Then it needs to be expressed in all the preparatory steps before actually doing what you want to do. The ratzon needs to create the seder.
_____________
Written by Rabbi Rapport
Torah is not about developing. It is about changing!
When we want to improve on something, it requires avodah…
We have a problem nowadays with listening to others. We…
Ameilus in Torah means to naturally flow from one point…
Ameilus is a mehalech. The mehalech protects us from the…
A new approach to learn how to relate to the…
Why do people work so hard in their jobs? Is…
Seder is not about being organised in doing what we…
If you offer to buy your wife a cake to…
We think that mitzvah observance is all about worrying whether…