After returning from abroad, I always find interesting things from my trip to think about. Whilst I was in South Africa, many different people came to speak to me about their issues. Initially, I was surprised that they had all waited to speak to me and that they couldn’t have spoken to someone else local.
The problem with listening
I think the problem is that not many people are able to listen to others.
Why are there so few people who can do this?
It is not due to a lack of interest. Rather, the cause is that people lack a process for listening. The same issue also has ramifications for how people relate to their friends.
Last vaad, we spoke about going away from the camp (without knowing exactly where we are heading, we at least establish clearly for ourselves where we are right now). I spoke with some people after the last vaad who made an effort to put what we discussed into practice. They told me that they tried it out in their learning. They wrote down the step in the sugyah where they were holding, without knowing where they were heading. It significantly improved the productivity of their learning.
How to listen
Let us apply this to the issue of knowing how to listen. When we speak to somebody, he wants to be related to by where he is, not by where he needs to be. Let me give you an example. I had a tremendous friend, Reb Yonah Rechnitzer z’l.
We lived on Sorotzkin Street with nine children. The house was always a balagan. I spoke to my friend Yonah for advice. In a normal situation, when a person asks another for advice, given that the Charedi world is so full of incidents involving gedolim, the following incident with the Chazon Ish automatically comes to mind. When a man came to the Chazon Ish and said his wife was not coping with managing the household, the Chazon Ish told him to take a broomstick and do some of the household chores himself.
To relate to the friend’s current predicament
To answer a petitioner based on a gedolim story means to ignore where the friend or petitioner is holding. Where he is holding is his ‘camp’. Yonah didn’t reply with this. Instead, he told me that I could move to a more spacious apartment, and I did. We moved to Ramot, and it was the best decision that I ever made!
Yonah took very seriously where I was holding. Most people fail to consider the current location of their friend or the petitioner. Instead, they focus solely on the solution.
In South Africa, I felt this. Lots of baalei teshuvah came to speak to me. Often, with baalei teshuvah, the husband or wife tends to move more quickly in their Yiddishkeit than the other. This was the common problem about which they came to consult me. I could have told them, from experience, that over time things like this get solved. Saying something like this, though, would constitute a lack of relating to his problem, which he is currently in.
I spoke to a baal teshuvah in South Africa about such issues. I didn’t have any solution for him. I related to his current situation and he was so happy.
So, the importance when we learn, in knowing where we are up to at any given point, is equally applicable in bein odom lechaveiro. Here, we also need to relate to where the friend is now and not to the solution for the future.
A few days ago, a baby with Down syndrome was born. For me to have said to the parents that the Chazon Ish used to stand up for such a child would have meant that I could not relate to the ‘camp’ where they were currently holding. Bein odom lechaveiro means to be together with our friend, wherever he is-whether this means to rejoice with him or to be in pain with him.
I have dealt with a set of parents who lost a baby in a cot death. They both said that people were coming to comfort them, saying that their baby must have had a very special neshamah that only needed a tikkun from three months. They commented that if it was as good as the comforters made out, would they like to switch places?! People can unintentionally be very cruel and focus on the solution without relating to the person’s pain.
Towards the end of the iggeres hateshuvah, Rabbeinu Yonah says that for yiras shomayim a person needs to find one or two friends and when necessary, the friend(s) can give him rebuke.
Simply put, we understand this to mean we need to find a friend to serve as our mashgiach. This is not what he means. Rabbeinu Yonah wants us to find friends who relate to us for who we are, and even when we do an aveirah, they still relate to us for having done aveiras.
In my experience, people want to speak about themselves in a way that allows them to be themselves and be listened to in this capacity.
Nowadays, people do not find this a possibility. Rabbinic people are expected to find solutions. This pressure is holding Rabbinic people back from relating to the petitioner’s predicament and is instead pushing them to look for solutions.
Once, someone came to Reb Aron Leib Shteinmann zt’l, saying that the social service wanted to take his children away. Reb Aron Leib didn’t provide any solutions. Instead, he just cried with the man. He felt the other’s pain. This is how to relate to another’s predicament!
Married couples tend to find a solution for the spouse without listening to the spouse’s pain. This needs to be worked on.
Written by Rabbi Rapport