Home > Lessons > Morality > Planning or Willpower > Plan Your Life – or Willpower? > A person is born to work – Sanhedrin 99b the second pshat of Raschi

A person is born to work – Sanhedrin 99b the second pshat of Raschi

New!

Ameilus is a mehalech. The mehalech protects us from the yetzer hara. We are simply not interested in doing aveiros!

We will continue with the series of vaadim from before Pesach.

We learned a certain chiddush from the Mishnah in Avos that the ‘yegiyah’ of Torah and melachah ‘mashkachas avon’. We explained this by saying that when a person is involved in a process, the yetzer hara has no opportunity to enter. Being involved in the process ensures that even when the yetzer hara comes to attack, the preoccupation in the process takes away the urge to be drawn after him.

Reb Yerucham’s understanding of ameilus

Reb Yerucham in Daas Chochmah Umussar chelek beis explains ‘odom leomol nivra’ (Sanhedrin 99b) to mean that a person needs to work with all his kochos to the point of exhausting them. This is unlike our explanation that the ameilus is the involvement in a process.

One question on Reb Yerucham’s pshat from the gemorah Sanhedrin 99b is how to understand the gemorah saying that omel peh might refer to sichah-what does it mean that a person has been created to exhaust all his kochos for sichah?

A proof for Reb Yerucham’s way of learning is that the gemorah brings a support, that man was created for omel peh of Torah (and not sichah), from Rovah, that all human bodies are ‘drufteki’. Rashi explains this to mean ‘tarchonin’, meaning that all bodies were created for omel. This is like Reb Yerucham, who says that ameilus refers to tirchah and to using up all of one’s kochos.

A different understanding in ameilus-organisation

However, Rashi in his second pshat on drufteki says that it means ‘a long bag that we place money in, (Rashi continues) so too our bodies (are created) to accept and bring into them words (of Torah). Happy are those who are zocheh and become a nartek (utensil) for Torah.

What does Rashi mean by a ‘long’ bag?

A long bag lets you see even the smallest coins inside. The long bag does not serve the simple function of stopping things from falling onto the floor. Rather, it facilitates the storing of something in an organized fashion.

If we take this second pshat of Rashi and plug it back into the gemorah, we can read the statement that man was created for ameilus in a different way than how Reb Yerucham learns. Ameilus does not refer to using all of our kochos. Rather, it refers to being involved in an organized process (like the organized bag).

I personally carried out this explanation of ameilus. I, together with my son, erected a new set of shelves last Friday and again on Sunday. On Friday from 10 in the morning until 5 in the afternoon, we were working. For these seven hours, I was a holy man! I didn’t have even one hirhur aveirah the whole time. I ate only a very small amount during it because I was preoccupied with the mehalech.

It was a whole mehalech. We couldn’t just take all the seforim down straight away, otherwise we wouldn’t have been able to work in the room. Rather, we needed to take some down at a time. We had to erect all the shelves in a straight fashion. There were many steps in the amel melachah of constructing the shelves. 

Working with wood and metal takes time. It took me two days! Amidst this, I made a mistake. I drilled a hole too close to an existing one, making it far too large and unusable. I didn’t despair from having made the mistake. Many people, upon making mistakes, give up. This is because they are not in a mehalech. When we are in a mehalech, even the mistakes teach us.

This was omel melachah. I am not trying to become a carpenter, but I experienced real omel melachah, not that I was sweating, but I worked without interruption. I saw from my life experience; I know how to create omel melachah. However, how do I create omel torah?

Omel melachah is not really part of our life. It’s the material which makes the mehalech-the wooden shelves and the iron that connects the shelves to the wall require a mehalech to make them work. In contrast, the omel peh is much closer to our lives.

Even the body has a mehalech

Let us explain. The body life is built off a mehalech. From the smallest cell to the largest body, everything runs on organization (mehalech). The organization of the body attempts to prevent things that will interfere with it from entering. If, for example, the wrong type of food is consumed, it will cause damage to the mehalech, the body will oppose it and try to eliminate it.

Omel sichah is very similar to this. Rashi says the bag is long and organized. This is being used to describe omel peh of Torah. This means that omel means organized. Omel Torah means organizing the Torah, and this is a process. 

Omel peh means organizing your speech in order to bring out your thoughts in the correct way. During this time, nothing else can enter. Occasionally, I have a joke, and I feel the need to say it. However, the joke is not part of the giving over of the mehalech. Such a joke can interfere with the mehalech.

Life and Torah cannot be interrupted.

When I built the shelves with my son, we took breaks from the job (process) every so often for jokes and food. These are not part of the mehalech, but it doesn’t make a problem. However, as far as life is concerned, there is no option for a break. If the heart takes a break, life ceases to continue. The mehalech of life cannot have a break.

Similarly, the mehalech of Torah cannot have a break. Even the mehalech of omel sichah cannot have a break. When a person speaks, they need to retain concentration. Being involved in any process cannot be done while engaging in other matters at the same time. 

Each omel requires different levels of involvement. Omel melachah can tolerate some interruptions, though they may cause the ‘thread’ to be lost somewhat. However, the involvement in the mehalech of omel sichah is lost from even a slight diversion. Omel torah requires the highest level of involvement.

So, according to Reb Yerucham, ameilus hatorah prevents a person from committing aveiras because his kochos are exhausted and he has no further kochos with which to commit aveiras. According to my explanation, on the other hand, based on the second pshat in Rashi, the reason ameilus stops a person from aveiras, despite his having kochos with which to sin, is that he is too involved to be interested in sinning. He isn’t safe from sinning because he fights the yetzer. Rather, he is safe from sinning because he is so involved in the mehalech that he has no interest in anything else, including the yetzer.

I experienced this in shaar aleph, perek dalet of Nefesh Chaim. I was so involved in this new pshat that I thought I would faint! This doesn’t often happen, though. Nonetheless, we need something that makes us walk on an organized path, for melachah and for Torah.


Written by Rabbi Rapport

Work means creating the next step

8

Planning or willpower sixth Vaad – yegias shneihem mashkachas avon

6

More Shiurim

12/06/2026

כ"ו סיוון תשפ"ו

Torah is not about developing. It is about changing!

05/06/2026

י"ט סיוון תשפ"ו

When we want to improve on something, it requires avodah…

01/05/2026

י"ד אייר תשפ"ו

Ameilus in Torah means to naturally flow from one point…

09/01/2026

י"ט טבת תשפ"ו

We think that mitzvah observance is all about worrying whether…

Login

Registration

First Name*
Last Name*
User Name*
Email*
Password*
Confirm Password*

Receive the shiur via email

What would you like to receive?