Home > Lessons > Morality > Planning or Willpower > Plan Your Life – or Willpower? > Tora wants change not only development

Tora wants change not only development

New!

Torah is not about developing. It is about changing!

Torah is not about developing. It is about changing!

In the last vaad, we discussed the Torah’s demand that we leave the place where we are to improve our avodas Hashem. We will consider this further and then make it more practical.

The Mashgiach once told us that when we make a kabbalah, we must base it on a Torah source or an incident from a gadol that we heard.

 At the time, I didn’t understand why the Mashgiach said this. We are talking about making kabbalos about our own lives. If so, why can’t we develop ourselves in the way that we see fit, without needing a Torah source?

We need to understand that the core point of Torah is to change our whole life around. Chazal say that there is no ‘mitzvah kalah’ that techiyas hamesim doesn’t depend upon. Techiyas hamesim is the time when everything will change, and the world will be different. If even the smallest mitzvah can cause such a significant change, this shows us that the Torah wants us to change our lives and leave where we currently are.

The chiddush of Torah

Interestingly, Torah wants us to change to a new place, yet at the same time Torah always speaks to us in our current place, commanding us in mitzvos or telling us how to live in our current location. So, on the one hand, the Torah wants us to be in a different place from where we are currently. On the other hand, it relates to us where we are currently holding.

This means that there is a chiddush in Torah: it speaks to us in our current capacity, but in a way that we will change.

Not to ‘develop’ but to ‘change’

In English the word we use to describe the process of moving to a new place is to ‘develop’. The word is built up from the word ‘envelop’-hidden inside and ‘de’ velop means to bring out the hidden thing inside the envelope. In German, the word for develop is entvikalt- vikalt means to be wrapped up, and ‘ent’vikalt means to unwrap it. In Hebrew, we say hitpatchut from the expression pesichah, meaning “to open up.”

All these linguistic expressions show that the idea of development is that the mindset is already in place, only that it needs to be brought out, which is the development. This is like a tree that has everything contained in its roots, only that it needs to be developed.

Torah doesn’t want development. Torah wants us to change!

Changing within our current place

People often think that change means we need to focus on getting ourselves to a place where we are not currently. This is not true. Rather, we need to make changes, but whilst focusing on where we currently are.

Through the chiddush of Torah, we can focus on where we are, and by taking a step with Torah, we can step away whilst paying attention to where we currently are. 

People think that Torah is a way of teaching us how to realize our potential in the right way. People also think of the Torah as an instruction book on how to develop the world in the best way without running into contradictions. The Torah’s aim is not to bring out potential in the best way! When the Torah gives us a mitzvah such as kiddush on Shabbos or bein odom lechaveiro, the point that the Torah wants us to achieve is a radical change.

My understanding of the Mashgiach’s words is that before making any kabbalah, we need to use the chiddush of the Torah, which allows us to change ourselves without needing to focus on going to a new place.

In other words, we think that to make a change means that we need to leave our current location for a new one. The fact of the matter is that this is not true-we stay in the same location. 

One might think that if we are not moving away, this would naturally mean we cannot do anything other than develop the potential that lies within us in our current location. However, due to the chiddush of the Torah, we can stay in the same location with ourselves but still make changes to ourselves.

Now that we have established this new concept of what Torah really wants from us, let’s explain how to make this practical.

Let me give an example. I personally do not want to just be engrossed in the Nefesh Hachaim and Torah without being connected with my children and grandchildren at the same time. I am older, and I know that my family needs me.

In order to make myself want to take a real interest in my family this requires being a different person. It is not sufficient to just reach out for a different behaviour. Rather, it requires an internal change. 

Before the Mashgiach, I had a Rebbe who was a talmid of Reb Eliyahu Dessler, and he learned with me very interesting things. We learned the whole of the Rakanti on the Torah. We learned the Radvaz on taamei hamitzvos. We learned mainly Rishonim. Most of our learning was focused on kabbalah, which is what Rav Dessler was into.

I then met the Mashgiach in Beer Yaakov, and he said that I needed to put all these seforim away. The extent of the seforim I used were a shas, Rambam, the rishon on the masechtah we were learning, one volume of daas chochmah umussar, mesillas yesharim, and shaarei teshuvah. 

In those days, it was frowned upon to go into the otzer haseforim. Somebody who knew how to learn didn’t need to glance around at different seforim to take his interest-he was expected to have enough stimulation and ability to learn by himself. (This is not how it is nowadays!)

One bein hasedorim I went to look in the otzer. Nobody saw me. I found the Radvaz on the taamei hamitzvos. I began to cry because I wanted to learn these sort of seforim again. They used to be my life!

I went to ask the Mashgiach. I told him that I used to learn with a Rebbe, Dr Kahn from Montreaux. I told him that he was a talmid of Rav Dessler and what sort of seforim we used to learn. He knew him.

The Mashgiach asked whether, when I learned these types of seforim, my tefillos changed. I said yes. He said that if so, I can continue to learn them. As he said this, I remember feeling this great load being lifted off me.

Then unexpectedly he said to me ‘do you know (based on learning these type of seforim) how you will look when you will be an odom gadol?’ I responded that they gave me a foggy look! He laughed and continued, saying that without learning mussar, you will never know. The sifrei kabbalah are not built for that. They serve a great function but not one which enables you to know how being an odom gadol looks.

His intention was that being an odom gadol is out of our realm. When it is only a matter of development, we can consider how we will develop. We all naturally have goals of how we hope to develop. We can have role models of how we hope to develop. However, this doesn’t give us a picture of how we will look as an odom gadol. This is just a way of avoiding working on ourselves.

When we learn mussar, we learn about things outside of ourselves. We learn about things that are not already within us/things which are not our inherent potential. For example, when we learn mussar about paying an interest in our family, we will learn that this is the subject of nosei b’ol chaveiro. It is not about simply becoming a nice person. Rather, it’s a question of changing ourselves as people.

Making the change

The Torah teaches us how to change. The first time when I really worked on making a Torah-sourced change was from the Alter from Kelm, Chochmah umussar,chelek 1-this is where I first learned about the opportunity to make small changes to leave my place and become a new person in the area of nosei b’ol chaveiro.

We always want more-I always say that we who have 100 always want 200. This doesn’t mean that we just want more. It means we focus on what we have (100), but what we want more of comes from what we already have. This means that we want a change.

We need to look around and find where in the Torah we have the opportunity to make small steps but ones that will change ourselves.

I was in a certain yeshiva in the 1970s. I was there for half a year. It was not good for me. The Rosh Yeshivah was very authoritative in his thinking. I had come from school in Switzerland, where I was not an obedient student! I needed to leave. 

The Mashgiach from the yeshivah, a very good person, wanted me to return to the yeshivah. He came to my parents’ house in Switzerland, spoke to my mother, and said that if I came to their yeshivah, I would come back a different person. Upon hearing this, my mother almost threw him out of the house with her own hands! She said, ‘I do not want a different son. I want my son!’  What the Mashgiach meant could not be communicated to someone outside the Torah world. He didn’t mean that I would be unrecognisable.  

The Torah demands change from us, not development.   


Written by Rabbi Rapport

HAFTR – working on connection

12

The Omol to take a first step in Avoda

10

More Shiurim

05/06/2026

י"ט סיוון תשפ"ו

When we want to improve on something, it requires avodah…

01/05/2026

י"ד אייר תשפ"ו

Ameilus in Torah means to naturally flow from one point…

09/01/2026

י"ט טבת תשפ"ו

We think that mitzvah observance is all about worrying whether…

Login

Registration

First Name*
Last Name*
User Name*
Email*
Password*
Confirm Password*

Receive the shiur via email

What would you like to receive?