Surprisingly, Reb Yerucham says that chitzoniyus is the essence and not the penimiyus!
Home > Lessons > Holidays > Yamim Noraim > Elul 2026 > First Vaad Elul – what is Pnimius
Surprisingly, Reb Yerucham says that chitzoniyus is the essence and not the penimiyus!
Elul Shiur 1 – What is Pnimius
The Nefesh Hachaim in perek 17 begins to speak about teshuvah and says, ‘we will explain the connection between nefesh, ruach and neshamah (the penimius of the person) and this is the ikkar of teshuvah’.
We all think that the ikkar idea of teshuvah is about changing and improving our actions.
It could be true that a side effect of our bad actions is a disconnection between our nefesh, ruach, and neshamah, and that, therefore, part of improving our actions is reconnecting our nefesh, ruach, and neshamah. Nevertheless, this is still only a side effect of teshuvah. The nefesh hachaim is saying more than this. The essential point of teshuvah is to work inside ourselves in a place beyond our actions-in our penimius.
What does the nefesh Hachaim mean?
Chitzoniyus and Penimius
We need to understand what penimius means. However, to understand penimius, let us first understand chitzoniyus.
Reb Yerucham in chelek 1 of Daas Chochmah Umussar at the end of maamar 34 says ‘that based on this maamar it is clear not like how we are accustomed to think that the penim is the ikkar and everything is for the sake of arriving at the penim. Rather, it’s the opposite. The chitzoniyus is the ikkar and the penimius has been created to arrive at the chitzoniyus.’
Clearly, we need to understand what real chitzoniyus is.
It is not an external description such as wearing a hat and a white shirt.
Chitzoniyus-well defined
Chitzoniyus means being clear-cut and well-defined. In other words, chitzoniyus means being revealed. The reason why chitzoniyus is the ikkar is that the Torah wants things to be clearly revealed.
On Rosh Hashanah we speak about malchus shomayim. We ask, ‘Give Your fear’, ‘Give Your honor’ so that they should be revealed everywhere.
Chitzoniyus is not about physicality and externality. For example, the Nefesh Hachaim calls a malach a chitzonyus existence. Have you ever seen a malach? A malach is not a lowly physical being.
A malach is a chitzoniyus existence because he is clearly defined. He is given a job, and this is what he is.
Penimius-doubtful and lack of clarity
What does penimius mean? The Mesilas Yesharim gives a maze as a mashal for avodas Hashem. The purpose of a maze is to reach a well-defined centre. In other words, according to our definition of chitzoniyus, avodas Hashem requires us to reach a point of clearly defined chitzoniyus.
Halachah is very well defined. For example, halachah says that when we wear tefillin we mustn’t have any foreign thoughts. This is very difficult, but we call it avodah. The halachos which are hard to keep we call avodah. Whereas the easy halachos to keep we call them halachah. This is incorrect. Even not having foreign thoughts whilst wearing tefillin is a clearly defined halachah.
Avodah-entering the maze
If everything is halachah, what is avodah? Avodah means entering the maze. This occurs when we doubt how to reach the clearly defined central point. Something is unclear to us. The avodah is the penimius where we have a doubt. Many people want everything clear without any doubt. If this is one’s approach, then it means that they have never entered the maze of avodah.
Similarly, if a person enters the centre of the maze and sees where they need to go, they think their problems are solved. However, the maze is built so that seeing the centre means you can never find the correct way. In other words, clarity does not give you a direction and will even hinder you from finding your way in life.
Avodah requires doubt
For example, I have a very close friend from the Mir, the mashgiach, Reb Binyomin Hatzaddik. He is a wonderful role model. He is truly a ‘clean’ tzaddik in every respect. If a bachur or avreich decides to use Reb Binyomin as a role model, they will never be able to emulate him. Having clarity about where we need to reach holds us back from reaching our goal. Clarity prevents us from working on our penimius. A prerequisite for working on penimius is ‘doubt’.
Another example is how to look at the following shikkul hadaas of the mashgiach when he was learning in the Mir yeshivah when it was in chutz laaretz. He wanted to write down the divrei torah that he had heard in yeshivah. There were two options. He could have written down the shmuzzen from Reb Yerucham or the shiur klali from R Laizer Yudel. He decided to write down the shiur klali of Reb Laizer Yudel. Why? He had more of a leaning towards writing down Reb Yerucham’s shmuzzen. Therefore, he decided to write the shiur klali instead, against his natural tendency.
Many people would say that, based on this maaseh rav of the mashgiach, we have insight into the mashgiach’s thought process. Subsequently, when confronted with a similar situation, people would think that they have clarity on how to make such a decision.
Torah Umesorah in America wanted to adopt a well-known shitah in chinuch that emphasizes presenting dilemmas to talmidim for them to solve. They asked the mashgiach if he agreed with their stance. He was very strongly opposed to this approach for chinuch. He said that Torah is based on clarity.
In keeping with the words of the mashgiach, halachah is very clearly defined in a seif in Shulchan Aruch. The only doubt needed is regarding how to approach the halachah and its clarity. The centre of the maze of the Mesillas Yesharim is the clarity of the Torah and halachah. However, the surrounding area (lack of clarity) is where our avodah is.
We all want clarity. This means that we are afraid of our unclear penimius! To allow ourselves into our penimius, we need to live with a certain level of doubt.
The maze of avodah aims to work with unclarity and doubts
The Mesillas Yesharim is not telling us that a person who has reached the central point of the maze should tell us all the directions how to get to the centre. If so, we lose the maze.
I have two proofs to learn the Mesillas Yesharim in this way:
Firstly, he says to overcome the maze requires weighing up the loss of the mitzvah against its reward. Only the person himself knows how much reward he attributes to an aveirah-the person in the centre isn’t privy to such information.
Secondly, if the person in the middle simply gives you directions how to reach the middle, of course you will succeed. If so, why does the mesillas yesharim say that after the man in the centre advises you, you still wouldn’t be able to see the toeles of this truth until you actually arrive in the centre of the maze?
We need to find different ways to reach the centre of the maze. It could be that, for example, working on controlling your taavos achilah so that you can sit at a chasunah without feeling the need to eat anything and have great gaavah from this, maybe is a mehalech. Whilst gaavah is not good, maybe if this helps us reach the ‘centre’ and control taavas achilah, this is worthwhile. This is just one example. We need to find different ways to achieve what the Torah wants of us.
It is not sufficient to be spoon-fed what direction to take to reach our chitzoniyus. We ourselves need to think it through- after all, it’s our penimius that we are thinking through.
Penimius of teshuvah
Teshuvah is based on the penimius, as the Nefesh Hachaim says. Teshuvah needs to affect our actions, but the ikkar teshuvah is done in our penim.
_______
Written by Rabbi Rapport
If we broaden our concepts, we can understand the words…
Nobody would say to learn the peirush of Reb Leib…
Kabbalas ol malchus shomayim is the recognition that what we…
When we do teshuvah, we do not need to feel…
We must change ourselves through teshuvah. However, when trying to…
This is the mussaf of Rosh Hashonah. It is scary…
We need to daven in a way that fits the…
Tefillah is not about asking Hashem for things in our…
Klal Yisroel have had a harsh year since last Rosh…
How can we make Teshuva simple? We need an approach…